While the focus of British relations
with Abu Dhabi, and the
wider United Arab Emirates,
is today set firmly in the present, with a
commitment to the building of a continuing
close relationship in the years to come,
the origins of British links with the UAE go
back over two hundred years. Some of
this earlier history is relatively well-known,
such as the signing of 1820 of treaties
between the British Government in India
and the Rulers of what were to become
the Emirates
. Less well-known, though, is the fact
that a variety of British sailors, scientists,
political officers and others made major
contributions to the early collection of dataabout the country. One such contribution
was to the charting of the waters of the
Gulf, from the late 18th Century until the
1950s. Indeed, all marine charts of the
UAE's waters are still largely based on the
data collected by British hydrographers.
British scientists, historians and
others continue to contribute to
knowledge of the Emirates today
- part of a relationship between the
two countries that has always gone far
beyond business and politics.
The article that follows is abridged,
with permission, from a longer article that
appeared in Volume 15.2 of the journal
Tribulus, published by the Emirates
Natural History Group, in 2005.
In 1953, I was serving as a
watch-keeping officer on board HMS
Dalrymple, carrying out a detailed survey
of the waters of the UAE to the west of
Sir Bani Yas, where soundings on the
Admiralty chart were still based on those
obtained in 1823 by Lieutenant John
Michael Guy of the Bombay Marine, the
navy of the British East India CompanyOne afternoon I was in charge on the
bridge running lines of soundings in an
east-west direction in a comparatively
flat bottom. At the end of my watch I
retired to my cabin for a well-earned rest,
but was soon woken up by a rumbling
noise that lasted about thirty seconds.Dashing up on deck, I spotted a dirty
brown patch in the water astern. We
had run over an uncharted isolated reef
and the rumbling noise I had heard
was branch coral being broken off by
the ship's bottom, fortunately without
doing any major damage to the ship.
The following day I was sent away in
a boat to examine the reef in detail,finding it very small in extent. Being
a new discovery, it was named Webb
Rock in honour of the senior British naval
officer in the Gulf. It is now described in
Admiralty sailing directions as
: Webb Rock (24o 05' N; 52o 15' E), with
less than 1.8 m over it, lying 6¼ miles
offshore NW of Jabal Barakah, should
be given a wide berth; soundings give no
indication of its proximity, nor can it be
seen even in good conditions, except at
very close range whence the dark brown
coral can be distinguished; there is no
sand on it to give the usual warning of
lighter coloured water.
Although the general outline of
the Arabian Gulf was known to Arab
scholars from an early date, European
cartographers remained largely
ignorant of the area. In the earliest
surviving printed maps, the Gulf has a
rectangular shape, derived more from
imagination than from observation, with
its largest dimension being east/west
rather than north-west/south-east. By
the early sixteenth century, the general
outline of the Gulf was depicted much
more realistically, particularly on its
north-eastern side which by then was
being visited by European ships. Since
such ships rarely, if ever, ventured
along the southern shores of the Gulf,
the coastline of the UAE continued to
be based largely on imagination. When
John Thornton published his chart in
The English Pilot: The Third Book in
1703 any additional information was
confined mainly to the north-eastern side
of the Gulf with virtually no information
at all about the coast and islands now
comprising the UAE
The first detailed survey of the Gulf
was carried out between 1785 and
1787 by John McCluer of the Bombay
Marine, which Alexander Dalrymple,
Hydrographer to the East India Company,
published in 1788. This chart, however,
did not cover the waters of the UAE since
at the time there was no incentive for the
British to examine the southern side of
the Gulf since it appeared to offer little.
in the way of trading possibilities. The
inhabitants of the coastal settlements
to the east of Dubai were also viewed,
with good cause, as being unfriendly
to European shipping. Indeed it was as
a result of attacks by Qasimi vessels,
based principally on Ra's al-Khaimah,
that eventually brought British warships
to UAE waters. During these operations
the Minerva, which had been captured
by the Qawasim, was recaptured in
November 1809 and set on fire in front of
Ra's al-Khaimah by the schooner Prince
of Wales, assisted by boats from the
Chiffone and Caroline
.During British
operations against
the Qawasim in
1809 and 1810,
Captain John
Wainwright of HMS
Chiffone acquired
a great deal of
hydrographic
information, which
he forwarded to
the Admiralty. In his report he noted that
a frigate could not approach within four
miles of Ra's al-Khaimah and that from
'Rumps' (Rams) to Sharjah the coast was
low and indifferently planted with dates.
It was also indented with a number of
creeks affording shelter to potentially
hostile vessels. To the west the land,
as far as Bahrain, was called by the
inhabitants the 'Coast of Danger' and
was completely unknown to Europeans,
with many shoals reported to lie off it.
Wainwright concluded by advocating
that a survey of the whole of the Gulf
was highly desirable, pointing out that
although McCluer's chart was the best
one available, it was erroneous in the
configuration of the coast.
Attacks on passing shipping continued
in spite of the presence of British
warships in the Gulf and eventually a
major British expedition was sent against
the Qawasim in 1819-20. Accompanying
the expedition was Lieutenant Thomas
Remon of the Engineers who produced a
plan showing the locations of the villages
that were attacked as well as individual
plans of six of them. The positions of the
towers and forts destroyed during the
expedition are depicted on the plans. As
a result of this expedition, treaties were
signed in January 1820 between the
British and the Rulers of the Coast, the
beginning of what was to become the
Trucial States (the present UAE).
Because of growing British interest
in the Gulf, Captain Hurd, Hydrographer
to the Admiralty, published the first
British Admiralty chart of the Gulf
on 21 September 1820, in which he
incorporated the surveys and comments
made by Wainwright, together with those
of McCluer and others. At the western
end of the coast of the present-day UAE,
in what is now western Abu Dhabi, the
chart carries the legend 'This part of the
Coast is unknown'. Some soundings
are also shown on the chart between
Dubai and a position some 70 miles
south-west with the legend along the
adjacent coastline 'Low sandy Coast
with Trees some Forts and small Villages
interspersed'. The only part of the coast
of present-day UAE which is depicted on
this chart with any accuracy is from the
Musandam Peninsula to the vicinity of Sharjah.
In 1820, following the signing of the
treaties with the Rulers, the Bombay
Marine gave instructions for a major
survey of the Gulf to be carried out by
Lieutenant Guy in the Discovery of 268
tons with Lieutenant George Barnes
Brucks as his assistant in the Psyche.
Guy started his survey the following year
at Ra's Musandam and by the end of
1822 he had reached Abu Dhabi. Since
by the end of 1824 Guy and Brucks
had extended their survey as far as
Ras Rakan at the head of the Qatar
Peninsula, it seems likely that they
completed the survey of the coast of
the UAE and its outlying islands by the
end of 1823. While Guy endeavoured
to base his surveys on a system of
triangulation, this was rarely possible
since in places the coast is fringed with
low and featureless islands up to 20
miles offshore, making triangulation
impracticable. In addition, because of
the difficult terrain, many of the bases
on which his survey depended were
measured by sound between the two
ships rather than on shore. Thus many
of Guy's surveys were controlled by
astronomical observations both on board
ship and on shore, where Guy used a
sextant on a stand or a theodolite to
observe for latitude by observing the
meridian altitude of the sun or a star.
Guy's longitudes were obtained by
chronometer measured from the meridian
of the English factory at Bassadore on
Qishm Island, whose longitude had
been fixed by meridian distances from
Bombay. He, therefore, had to return
to Bassadore at intervals to check the
errors of his chronometers and to obtain provisions. These were also obtained
during the survey from local Sheikhs,
who were very civil to the officers of
the surveying vessels. Soundings were
obtained by lead line from which the
height of the tide was subtracted to
reduce them to a low water datum. In
some parts of Guy's survey there are
numerous soundings, but in other parts
there are large areas with few soundings
or even no soundings at all, inevitable in
a survey which was principally aimed at
discovering the correct delineation of the
coastline and the positions and extent
of off-lying islands. Guy was faced with
the dilemma faced by all surveyors of his
generation when surveying a completely
unknown stretch of coastline. Such
a survey is inevitably a compromise
between absolute accuracy and
completing the survey to an acceptable
degree of accuracy in a reasonable
length of time. In such a survey it is
inevitable that not all dangers will be
discovered as we discovered to our cost
in the Dalrymple.
When Guy reached Khor Abdulla,
at the head of the Gulf, his health
gave way and Brucks took over the
survey and we must rely on the latter's
memoir, published in 1856, to learn
about Guy's survey. In it Brucks wrote
that Ra's al-Khaimah
.
was prior to the expedition in 1819-
20.... surrounded on three sides with
a wall, flanked with towers, and to the
south-westward of the town had a further
defence of strong square fort or Ghuree,
and was at that time supposed to be
defended by between six and seven
thousand men, including the auxiliaries
collected from the country round about,
and about eighty boats of different size,
from two hundred and fifty to forty or fifty
tons, some mounting eight and ten guns.
They also had about sixty or seventy
pieces of Cannon, of various descriptions,
but most of them would be considered
unserviceable by Europeans.
Brucks also commented on Sharjah and
Abu Heyle (Abu Hail):
Shargah...is long and narrow and open:
the defences are a fort a little inland,
mounting six pieces of Cannon together
with some detached towers. In case of
alarm from an enemy, it is stockaded
round with Date trees and wood...Shargah
sends from three to four hundred boats of
various sizes to the pearl fishery.
Aboo Heyle is a small village situated
about three miles to the SW of Shargah,
on the same creek with Khan village
on the other bank. They jointly contain
about two hundred and fifty inhabitants
of various tribes, mostly fishermen, and
are subject to Shargah.
Brucks described all the islands that
he and Guy surveyed. According to
him, Jezirat Arzanah was moderately
elevated and about six and a half miles
in circumference, while its south point,
like most of the islands, was low and
sheltered from the prevailing winds,
where good anchorage could be found
under the lee of the island. It had
no water. He considered that Jezirat
Zarakkuh (Zirku) was the highest island
off the south coast of the Gulf and that it
afforded good anchorage under its lee,
sheltered from the prevailing wind. It
too had no water. Sheltered anchorage
from northerly winds was essential
for the safety of the two ships since in
winter the shamal can blow at times with
considerable violence.
The results of the surveys carried out
by Guy and Brucks, with support from
Captain Haines, covering the waters
of the UAE, were drawn at the end of
the survey of the Gulf in 1830 on a
small scale chart, extending from the Musandam Peninsula to Khor Abdulla,
with the off-lying islands drawn on nine
large scale plans. On 1 January 1832,
James Horsburgh, Hydrographer to the
East India Company, published a chart
of the Gulf on two sheets based on these
surveys. The publication of this chart led
to the withdrawal of the 1820 Admiralty
chart, which thus was in publication for
a very short time. When the Admiralty
took over the charting responsibilities
of the East India Company in 1861, the
Hydrographer of the Navy continued to
publish Horsburgh's chart as charts 90
(a) and (b), but did not initiate further
major surveys of the coastal waters of
the UAE for over 100 years, although a
number of minor surveys of small extent
were carried out during this period.
Thus it was not until after the end of
World War II that Guy's survey was
finally superseded, when the discovery
of oil in the waters of the UAE led to the
area being surveyed in detail to modern
standards.
Lieutenant Commander Andrew David
served in the Arabian Gulf in the early
1950s and, in retirement, has made a
special study of British mapping in
the Gulf. The illustrations are taken
from originals in the archives of the
Hydrographic Office in Taunton.
|